Valentine’s Ice Cream – No Churn (with Video)

This Valentines Ice Cream recipe is sure to spark the love without all of the hassle. Creamy ice cream made with just a few ingredients. And the best part? It’s no churn! 

Are you choosing to stay in this Valentine’s Day but want to enjoy a special homemade sweet treat? Or maybe you’re celebrating as a family with your kids.

Either way, my no-churn Valentines ice cream fits the occasion. Serve it up with a batch of my Valentine’s Day Oreo Pops or easy Heart Cakesicles for a fun holiday treat.

I know it may still be cold in some parts of the country so ice cream may not be at the top of your list. But hey when you want it, you want it!

I love no churn ice cream because you don’t need an ice cream maker or even have to leave the house to enjoy this sweet treat. And if you want more ideas, be sure to check out these easy no churn ice cream recipes.

Even though we are making this version of homemade ice cream for Valentine’s day, I am going to share ideas on how to make this for other holidays and occasions. Like this easy peppermint ice cream version for the holiday season. I’ve also included our favorite mix-ins and ways to serve this easy frozen treat.

If you are feeling adventurous you can add it to the top of my Cast Iron Cookie Skillet or create an ice cream sundae bar for a party. And if you love ice cream don’t leave without checking out these homemade popsicles and float recipes: 

• Root Beer Float Popsicles {2 Ingredients!)
• Dragon Fruit Popsicles Recipe
• Banana Pudding Pops
• Orange Floats Recipe {2 Ingredients!}

What Does No Churn Ice Cream Mean?

If you’ve never made homemade ice cream, typically you would need an ice cream maker. One that you churn by hand or an electric version.

The churning against ice cubes and dry ice is what makes the ingredients harden up to make ice cream. 

You may be wondering how it is even possible to make ice cream without churning it. But you can, and it’s super easy! 

How long does it take to make no churn ice cream?

The longest part of the process is waiting for it to freeze. That part takes at least 4 hours, but it’s best when frozen overnight. 

Other than that, it only takes a few minutes after your gadgets are chilled to “make” ice cream.

Ingredients for Valentine’s Ice Cream 

• Heavy whipping cream
• Condensed sweetened milk
• Vanilla 
• Neon Pink gel food coloring – you can use other colors if you like. Just a heads-up red is a tough color to achieve – it usually takes a lot of red gel and it still may come out pink.
• Valentine’s Day sprinkles 
• Cones for serving – I like to use sugar cones but cake cones are good too

Other Gadgets Needed:

• Bread pan – to freeze the ice cream in
• Ice cream scooper – You probably already know this, but you should have an ice cream scoop on hand to keep from bending the handles on your good spoons. 
• Mixing bowl – you’ll need two
• Electric mixer – you do not want to mix homemade ice cream by hand, trust me! 

How to Make Ice Cream for Valentines Day

Freeze your mixing bowl, loaf pan, and beaters for at least 15 minutes before starting. 

Then take them out of the freezer, add the whipping cream to the bowl and mix on High with an electric mixer until it begins to thicken up. 

Beat in the sweetened condensed milk and vanilla extract. 

Separate the mixture in half, adding half to a second bowl. 

Squeeze pink food coloring into one bowl and stir until the cream mixture reaches your desired color. 

Pour the mixture from both bowls into the loaf pan, using a knife to swirl for a marbled look. 

Decorate the top with sprinkles and freeze. 

Tips for Making No Churn Ice Cream

• Freeze your loaf pan, mixing bowl, and mixing beaters before starting. This makes the process easier and helps the ice cream mixture thicken faster.
  
• Line your loaf pan with parchment paper if desired – it makes it easier to transfer the ice cream to a freezer container for longer storage. 

• If you are adding additional ingredients such as nuts or candies make sure they are chopped in small pieces. This makes it easier to eat because once they are frozen they become hard as rocks. 

• Don’t overdo it on the extract if you substitute the vanilla. Some extracts, like mint, can be very overpowering even in small amounts. 

Homemade No Churn Ice Cream Serving & Add In Suggestions 

If you want to jazz up your ice cream, be sure to load it down with toppings or pile it high in a waffle cone or make your own waffle bowls. You can also use these as add-ins if you prefer. 

• Syrups – chocolate, butterscotch, caramel
• Chopped nuts – pecans and walnuts work well with most flavors
• Hot fudge sauce 
• Candy
• Crumbled cookies 
• Whipped cream 
• Fruit 
• Chocolate chips 

Ice Cream Storage Instructions 

No churn ice cream will last for a month in the freezer if it is stored properly. 

• Make sure it is covered and sealed as tightly as possible to prevent freezer burn. 
• Storing in the back of the freezer is best because it’s less susceptible to warm air when you open and close the freezer on a regular basis. 
• If you line the pan with parchment paper before starting, you can easily transfer the ice cream to an airtight storage container.

Hosting a Valentine’s Day Ice Cream Party 

This is a fantastic idea and is super easy. Cover your table with a tablecloth and set up ice cream bowls, cones, spoons and napkins at one end.

Next add various-sized bowls to place your toppings in. We like to include cherry sauce and a variety of syrups in addition to sprinkles and nuts.

Keep your ice cream frozen until you are ready to serve. 

Jazz up the decor by grabbing some Valentine’s day banners and festive napkins. 

Use candy hearts as table decorations or toppings. 

Serve the ice cream in fancy glasses, or at least the ones that look fancy but are plastic. Those are best for younger kids and if they are disposable cleanup is a breeze. 

More Festive Desserts & Treats:

• Red White and Blue Charcuterie Board (Desserts)
• Bunny Bait Easter Snack Mix {No Bake}
• Red White and Blue Oreo Balls
• Grinch Edible Sugar Cookie Dough
• Cornflake Wreaths {No Bake}
• Chocolate Covered Cookie Dough Bites

**Save Valentines Day Ice Cream Recipe for Later**